January Sale - Secure Your Passwords

Should I Use a Password Manager? Pros, Cons & Our Honest Recommendation

The short answer is yes. Here's a detailed look at why password managers are worth it, the trade-offs to consider, and which one we recommend.

Tips for creating and managing secure passwords Strong passwords are essential, but managing them is the real challenge.

If you've ever asked yourself "do I really need a password manager?" or "are password managers worth it?", you're not alone. It's one of the most common cybersecurity questions people search for. The reality is that most of us know our password habits are bad, but we're not sure if a password manager is the right fix.

In this guide, we'll break down exactly what a password manager does, weigh the pros and cons honestly, and explain why we believe it's one of the single best investments you can make in your digital security.


1. What Is a Password Manager?

A password manager is a piece of software that securely stores all your passwords in an encrypted vault. Instead of memorising dozens (or hundreds) of passwords, you only need to remember one: your master password. The password manager handles everything else.

Here's what a typical password manager does:

  • Generates strong, random passwords for each account you create
  • Stores them securely using military-grade encryption
  • Auto-fills login forms on websites and apps so you never have to type a password
  • Syncs across all your devices — phone, laptop, tablet, work computer
  • Alerts you if any of your passwords appear in a data breach

Think of it as a digital safe for your credentials. You lock everything inside it, and only your master password can open it.

2. The Problem: Why Most People Have Weak Passwords

Before we discuss whether a password manager is worth it, let's be honest about the problem it solves. The average person has over 100 online accounts. That includes email, banking, social media, streaming, shopping, work tools, government portals, and more.

Nobody can memorise 100 unique, strong passwords. So what do people actually do?

  • Reuse the same password across multiple sites — studies show over 60% of people do this
  • Use simple, guessable passwords — "123456", "password", and "qwerty" still top the most-common lists year after year
  • Write passwords on sticky notes or store them in unencrypted files
  • Use slight variations — like "Password1!", "Password2!", "Password3!" — which cracking tools see through instantly

The consequences are real. In 2023 alone, over 8 billion records were exposed in data breaches worldwide. When attackers steal credentials from one breached service, they immediately try those same credentials on banking sites, email accounts, and social media — a technique called credential stuffing. If you reuse passwords, one breach can compromise your entire digital life.

This is the problem a password manager solves. It makes it effortless to have a unique, strong password for every single account. You can generate a strong password in one click and never worry about remembering it.

3. Password Manager Pros

Here are the concrete benefits of using a password manager:

Stronger Passwords Without the Effort

A password manager generates truly random passwords — 20+ characters with uppercase, lowercase, numbers, and symbols. These passwords are virtually impossible to crack with current technology. And since the manager remembers them, you don't have to sacrifice security for convenience.

Unique Password for Every Account

This is the single biggest security advantage. If one service gets breached, your other accounts remain safe because none of them share a password. Without a password manager, maintaining unique passwords across 100+ accounts is simply not realistic.

Auto-Fill Saves Time

No more typing passwords, no more "forgot password" resets, no more hunting through old emails. Your password manager fills in credentials instantly on websites and apps. It's actually faster than typing passwords manually.

Breach Monitoring

Premium password managers scan the dark web and known breach databases to alert you if any of your credentials have been compromised. This gives you time to change a password before an attacker can use it.

Secure Sharing

Need to share a Netflix login with family or a business account with a colleague? A password manager lets you share credentials securely without sending passwords over text or email where they can be intercepted.

Works Everywhere

Unlike browser-based password saving (which only works in that specific browser), a dedicated password manager works across all your browsers, apps, and devices. Switch from Chrome to Safari? Move from iPhone to Android? Your passwords follow you seamlessly.

4. Password Manager Cons

No tool is perfect. Here are the legitimate concerns and how to think about them:

Single Point of Failure

This is the most common objection: "If someone gets my master password, they get everything." It's a valid concern, but consider the alternative. Without a password manager, you're almost certainly reusing passwords — which means every breached service is a point of failure for all your other accounts. A single, strong master password protected by two-factor authentication is far more secure than dozens of weak, reused passwords scattered everywhere.

Cost

Premium password managers typically cost between $2 and $5 per month. Free tiers exist but come with limitations. Consider this: the average cost of identity theft to victims exceeds $1,000, not counting the time and stress of recovery. A few dollars per month is inexpensive insurance.

Learning Curve

There's a setup period where you need to install the app, create your master password, and begin saving credentials as you log into sites. Most modern password managers make this quite smooth with browser extensions and import tools, but it does require some initial effort. After the first week, it becomes second nature.

Dependence on the Tool

If the password manager service goes down or you forget your master password, accessing your accounts becomes difficult. Reputable managers offer emergency access features, recovery options, and offline vault access to mitigate this. The key is choosing a well-established provider.

🔐
Ready to Fix Your Password Habits?

Most people know they should use a password manager but keep putting it off. NordPass makes setup easy — import your existing passwords, install the browser extension, and you're protected in minutes.

Get NordPass with 50% discount →

Some links on this page are affiliate links. We may earn a commission if you make a purchase, at no extra cost to you.

5. The Verdict: Yes, You Should Use a Password Manager

If you're still on the fence, let's address the most common objections directly:

"I don't have anything worth stealing." You do. Your email account can be used to reset passwords for every other service you use. Your identity can be used to open fraudulent accounts. Even your streaming accounts have resale value on the dark web.

"My browser saves my passwords already." Browser password storage is a convenient starting point, but it's less secure than a dedicated manager. Browser-stored passwords are a primary target for malware, they lack strong encryption in many cases, and they don't work across different browsers or native apps. For more on this, see our article on whether it's safe to save passwords in Chrome.

"I have a system that works." If your system involves any form of password reuse, pattern-based passwords (like "Facebook1!", "Gmail1!"), or storing passwords in a spreadsheet or note, it's not as secure as you think. Attackers know these patterns.

"It's too expensive." The cost of a password manager is a fraction of the cost (financial and emotional) of dealing with a compromised account. Many offer family plans that cover five or more users for the price of a coffee per month.

Every major cybersecurity organisation — from the Australian Cyber Security Centre to NIST to the Electronic Frontier Foundation — recommends using a password manager. It is one of the most impactful, accessible security steps any person can take.

6. Our Recommendation: NordPass

There are several good password managers available. After evaluating the major options, we recommend NordPass for most people. Here's why:

XChaCha20 Encryption

While most password managers use AES-256 (which is excellent), NordPass uses XChaCha20 encryption — a modern algorithm that's faster, simpler to implement correctly, and considered the next generation of encryption standards. It's the same algorithm used by tech giants like Google for internal encryption.

Zero-Knowledge Architecture

NordPass encrypts your data on your device before it ever reaches their servers. They literally cannot see your passwords, even if they wanted to. If their servers were ever breached, attackers would only find encrypted data they cannot decrypt without your master password.

Cross-Platform Support

NordPass works on Windows, macOS, Linux, Android, iOS, and as a browser extension for Chrome, Firefox, Edge, Safari, Opera, and Brave. Your passwords sync seamlessly across all your devices.

Family Plan

The NordPass Family plan covers up to 6 users, each with their own private encrypted vault. This is an excellent way to get your whole household using a password manager without paying for individual subscriptions.

Data Breach Scanner

NordPass continuously monitors known data breaches and alerts you if any of your saved credentials, email addresses, or credit card details have been exposed. You'll know immediately if you need to change a password.

Built by Nord Security

NordPass comes from the same team behind NordVPN, one of the most trusted names in online privacy. They have a proven track record and the infrastructure to keep your data secure.

If you want to explore more about where to save passwords securely, we've covered that topic in a separate guide.

🔐
Start Protecting Your Passwords Today

NordPass uses next-gen XChaCha20 encryption, works on every device, and includes a data breach scanner. Set up takes less than 5 minutes.

Get NordPass with 50% discount →

Some links on this page are affiliate links. We may earn a commission if you make a purchase, at no extra cost to you.

7. How to Get Started with a Password Manager

Switching to a password manager is easier than you think. Here's a practical step-by-step approach:

  1. Choose a password manager. We recommend NordPass, but the most important thing is that you use one — any reputable option is far better than none.
  2. Create a strong master password. This is the one password you need to memorise. Make it long (16+ characters), use a passphrase of random words with numbers and symbols, and never use it anywhere else. Use our password generator if you need help.
  3. Install the browser extension and mobile app. This enables auto-fill so you can log in with one click.
  4. Import existing passwords. Most password managers can import passwords from your browser or a CSV file. This saves you from manually re-entering everything.
  5. Start using it naturally. You don't have to update all 100+ passwords on day one. Each time you log into a site, let the manager save the credential. When you create a new account, let it generate a strong password. Over time, your vault fills up organically.
  6. Gradually replace weak passwords. Use the manager's security audit or breach scanner to identify your weakest and most reused passwords. Update the most critical ones first — email, banking, and any account with payment information.
  7. Enable two-factor authentication. Turn on 2FA for your password manager account and for your most important accounts. This adds a second layer of protection even if a password is somehow compromised.

Within a week, you'll wonder how you ever managed without one.


8. Frequently Asked Questions

Yes. A password manager is one of the most effective steps you can take to improve your online security. It generates strong, unique passwords for every account and stores them securely so you never have to remember or reuse passwords. Security experts, including those at NIST and the Australian Cyber Security Centre, recommend using one.

Reputable password managers like NordPass use zero-knowledge encryption, meaning even the company cannot see your passwords. Your data is encrypted locally on your device before it ever reaches their servers. A password manager is far safer than reusing passwords, writing them on sticky notes, or saving them in an unencrypted document.

With a zero-knowledge password manager, even if the company's servers are breached, attackers only get encrypted data they cannot read without your master password. This is why choosing a strong master password is critical. No reputable password manager stores your master password or has the ability to decrypt your vault.

Free password managers provide basic functionality but often lack features like breach monitoring, secure sharing, cross-device sync, and priority support. For most people, a paid password manager offers significantly better value and protection. NordPass offers plans starting at a few dollars per month with a 50% discount available.

Yes. Browser-based password saving is convenient but less secure than a dedicated password manager. Browser password stores are a common target for malware, they lack advanced encryption, and they don't work across different browsers or non-browser apps. A dedicated password manager provides stronger encryption, cross-platform support, and additional security features like breach monitoring. Read more in our guide on whether it's safe to save passwords in Chrome.

Especially if you reuse passwords. Password reuse is one of the biggest security risks online. When one service is breached, attackers try those credentials on every other service — a technique called credential stuffing. A password manager makes it easy to have a unique, strong password for every account without memorising them.

Further Reading